Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Matthew's avatar

Hey Andrew,

Great work on this piece. I strongly agree with your point regarding neoconservative readings of Jacques Maritain. I will acknowledge the limits of my own expertise here. I have read a good portion, though not all, of his corpus, and he strikes me as more of an enigma than someone easily categorized as “right” or “left.”

In all honesty, I think the Garrigou-Maritain split is somewhat overstated as a true chasm within Catholic political theology. Prudentially, they differ quite a bit. Garrigou, of course, was a monarchist. Still, they seem to operate from largely similar first principles.

On that note, Maritain’s political theology in The Primacy of the Spiritual is deeply traditional, which is why I was somewhat surprised by the passage you cited from Integral Humanism. I have not yet read that work. It makes me wonder to what extent the development of his political thought reflects a certain temperamental responsiveness to the events of his age.

As you know, he was initially associated with Action Française before its condemnation by Pius XI, something he reflects on in The Primacy of the Spiritual. In the decades that followed, particularly in the 1940s and 1950s, he seems to take a more optimistic and modern-friendly turn. Yet by the end of his life, in The Peasant of the Garonne, his tone is markedly more pessimistic and critical of modern developments. There, he famously warns against “the Church kneeling at the altar of the world” and critiques the post-conciliar implementation.

In short, I think he is stranger than most "conservative" readings of him, but I think he has a traditionalist streak that is underemphasized because of his enthusiastic opposition to right-wing fascist governments in Spain and France. Thanks for the consideration

Best,

Matthew

PCH's avatar

I was born at around the same time. It is fascinating to see that there is a corner of Catholic thought seeking to rehabilitate such a throughly discredited anomaly in the history of Christendom (said anomaly being broadly the second half of 20th century’s goal to erase peoplehood - eventually only that of the European peoples - in fact only their peoplehoods - our enemy - that of all mankind St. Paul would add - and that of the Church has always been doggedly focused upon on this). I am no liberal economics idolater, nor interested in perpetuating Pax Americana on behalf of the state of anti-Christ, but by golly one gains a bit of empathy for one’s former self when you one sees just how warped the mind infected by leftism truly is. I am not mad that subsistence level poverty has been reduced so dramatically so quickly or that the last gasp of leftist credibility was shattered by the greater strength of its capitalist materialist superior (needless to say, whether those portions of the world incapable of sovereignty, let alone self-government in any meaningful sense, can, in prudence fruitfully be offered another chance at tutelage is a vexed question - the sole morally coherent and practically critical consideration of course being the degree to which such benevolent tutelage can be of service in preventing the fast-approaching ethnic cleansing of those nations having the recorded historical capacity of attaining mature civilizations). Sure, the myths associated with the second world war are important to dethrone, but it is precisely the by far greater monsters we served (usurious plutocracy and bolshevism [EL check reminder every 100-1000 words when reading history of either system] - far worse than a chauvinistic - embrace of national particularism required to mobilize the masses in age of mass politics - a rotten fruit of Luther and his comrades in 1789). The leveling, anti-hierarchical, Non Servium instinct on prideful display here is older perhaps than other evil, and to be sure, spiteful mutants and well-meaning water carriers (my wanting attempt to be adequately charitable to the misguided author whose intentions I will presume neither to know nor to judge without knowing) of the enemy will never be wholly absent in the fallen order we inhabit temporally (though the coming diminishment of many forms of toleration, which has become an anti-virtue, may, one prays, lessen the annoyance caused by both classes of person). That said, while we can and must reject the hatred of Creation and its inherent hierarchies, we must also remember joyfully Christ has already trampled it underfoot. Total victory has already been secured. Praise the Triune God that those trying to fight a rear guard action within Mother Church are passing from the scene. ¡Viva Franco! ¡Viva España!¡VIVA CRISTO REY!

2 more comments...

Keep reading

View all