Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jazmine Thérèse's avatar

Thank you for this write up Lucy — I recently gave a talk titled “Maidens, Mothers and Mystics: The Role of Catholic Women in the Church Through the Ages” and felt I could read from and about Hildegard all day — and still I learned a few new things from your article! I’m feeling very tempted these days to name our next daughter after her, if we are blessed with one!

Phillip F McCabe's avatar

You will be sorry for this post, as it will now cause more exposure to this witch, and here it is: "Hildegard’s visions violate the traditional Christian understanding of private revelation and the authority of the Church...." "her "abnormal gift" (often described by secular historians as visionary prophecy) as occultic in nature." "RJMI’s critique generally follows these points:

Rejection of Private Revelation: He maintains that the era of public revelation closed with the death of the last Apostle. He argues that any subsequent "prophetic" visions that attempt to add to or clarify doctrine—or that claim a direct, unmediated channel to the Divine—are deceptive.

The "Witchcraft" or Occult Classification: While mainstream history views Hildegard as a polymath and mystic, RJMI classifies her influence as witchcraft because he contends she operated under the power of demons, seduced others into heresy, and elevated her own subjective experiences above the objective deposit of the faith.

The Heretical Trajectory: He places her within a broader context of medieval figures whom he views as having helped corrupt the Church from within. He considers her popularity among modern readers as evidence of a "great apostasy" where individuals prioritize mystical or emotional experiences over the strict, traditional doctrine he defends.

You can find his specific arguments detailing why he labels her a witch and a deceiver in his various "True Catholic" online tracts and compiled encyclicals, where he methodically categorizes historical figures as either saints or agents of the adversary based on his strict adherence to his specific interpretation of Catholic tradition. His writings on this are typically indexed under his critiques of "false mystics" and "heretical saints." The above is from the ai helper at gab.com ai I use... More on her use of astrology, and demon possessed "rocks/stones" later when I get some time for this update....

8 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?